Thursday, February 18, 2016

So, I'm Thinking About This.

So here's something I'm thinking about.

Gah. This feels all nakedly confessional and awkward and I'm kind of embarrassed for myself because I think if I read this on someone else's blog, I'd feel that embarrassment you feel for people who maybe don't know well enough to be embarrassed for themselves. (David handles that kind of embarrassment really poorly, which is why he has a hard time with certain sitcoms.)

Anyway, I was thinking about how I still get e-mails from people--not too frequently, but more often than you might think--who have found my blog after a recent loss.

I write so much now about Zuzu and Coco and life five years in, that I'm not always sure my blog would even be very helpful to someone whose grief is fresh, though most of the time they mention that they have gone back into the archives so they are reading about 2011, otherwise known as The Black Hole of Grief. (What kills me most about those posts, which I can hardly stand to read, are the ones where I'm trying to be, like, cheerful. As though I can convince myself things are getting better. Because I really thought they were. But when I think back to those months and I know how miserable I still was, I want to go back and pat my old self on the head and say something like, "You're not feeling better yet. You will, but you're gonna need to give it more time.")

Anyway, I was thinking about how grateful I am that there are resources for people who have experienced loss now, and how the internet is a magical place.

But I was also thinking about books, and how I turned to them in desperation, seeking answers. I remember looking on Amazon and cringing at how heartbreaking the titles are, and not wanting to be one of those people who needed a f*cking book about stillbirth.

I loved reading Elizabeth McCracken's AMAZING memoir, An Exact Replica of a Figment of My Imagination. It helped me see that someone who was something like me had gone through this experience and survived it. (I also hated it, because WHY did this happen to her? And then me?)

It helped to read about someone else's experience. It helped most of all to connect with other people who were living it.

But I also wanted a guide. Like a handbook. Something like How to Be Okay When You Are Never Going to Be Okay Again. or What the Hell to Do When Your Life Completely Falls Apart and You are in Danger of Drowning in Your Own Tears. Maybe also How to Navigate Friendship When You Basically Hate the World. Basically, What to Do When the Entire World Conspires to Make You Believe You'll Bring Home a Baby, and Then You Don't. I wanted it divide up in specific categories--maybe how to survive, month by month. Or how to handle going back to work, ways to honor your baby's memory, what to do when you and your spouse are grieving differently and you're annoyed by how stereotypically gendered your expressions of grief seem to be. And I wanted the guide to be written by someone who felt real, like someone I could be friends with in real life, but who also maybe had some wisdom and understanding that I was missing.

There are some great books out there, but I don't think this book exists.

And I don't think I could write this book exactly. But I think maybe I could construct a framework and put out calls and ask a bunch of different people to help me write it.

I don't know that a book like this could get published. It seems doubtful, in fact. But it could sure as shit get self-published on Amazon so that someone who is desperate could put in the search terms to find it.

So that's what I'm thinking about.

I don't know why I'm thinking about it NOW, when it's 5+ years since my loss, except that babies keep dying and parents are still bewildered and overwhelmed and slogging through grief feeling isolated and desperately sending out e-mails to strangers on the internet because we have to find each other, because we need to hear someone tell us that we'll survive.

Also maybe because I recently read Elizabeth Gilbert's book Big Magic, and she talks about how when ideas come to you, you shouldn't ignore them or they'll leave you and they're a gift you might not be able to get back. This little idea keeps nudging me, even when I think it's stupid, or only three people would ever read it, or it would be so much work to end up self-publishing it and there would probably be typos I would miss and then people would be judgy and I don't even really know how to begin, and--most of all--I'm probably not the right person to take this on.

I could name a million reasons why I should just forget it. But I'm still thinking about it.

23 comments:

  1. Like a "how to" for grief? Or more like a "this is how I felt and this is what I did" kind of thing? If you were thinking of a collection of perhaps say essays or blog posts from different BLMS in a collective manner that sort of wove and told a story...that would be pretty awesome too. I'd love to contribute on this one.
    What ever you decide, I'm certain it would be helpful to anyone who needs it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think like a "how to"... with collections of short essays about "how" BLMs did it, so there's a wide variety of perspectives and options. I mean, obviously there's no "how" that fits everybody, but something that offers a path to recovery--physically and mentally and emotionally. I don't know. I'm definitely still trying to figure it out!

      Delete
    2. At the beginning, when I first lost Xavier, I desperately wanted someone to hold my hand and lead me through it. I felt weak, I felt incapable and I just wanted someone to assure me that I would survive, that I was taking the right path. If I could have covered my eyes and walked blindly down this path I would have. Like someone below posted, I just needed assurance that I would eventually not feel so broken, so damaged and so far removed from who I used to be. What you're planning makes me jealous for any one that gets to utilize it, because there was really nothing save for the blog posts I read and re-read (and clung to like a life line) from all our fellow BLMS (and some blds).

      Delete
  2. I think it's a good idea. You've already got a rough outline. Maybe develop that a little more, just so that the idea doesn't leave you, as you fear it might.

    Here's my ineloquent take on this (the ineloquence being the whole labeling a group as "people" and "they", but hopefully this will make sense).

    People dealing with this kind of profound loss are so angry at the world for telling them how they should feel, how long they should feel it - how dare anyone write the script for them, and tell them how long they get to wallow in their grief?! How dare they even use the word "wallow"? There is so much resistance and anger at those removed from the very close circle of grief of the directly affected. Grief is so isolating and restricting. And yet, they seek out someone, anyone, who might tell them that what they are feeling or experiencing is exactly right, a shared experience. They are desperate for some idea of what this thing is going to look like tomorrow or next week or next year. They want a script for it more than anything.

    How dare you tell me how to feel?? / Please, please, tell me that what I'm feeling is normal!! / Leave me alone!! / Please don't leave me or I might not make it through to the other side...

    Here is what I honestly feel: You have a gift that bridges this dichotomy in a way that I've never really seen before in someone that I know. I think you should go with your gut, and percolate on this some more. You've known me for several years now. I'm not the fawning fangirl type. I'm not in your club. I'm giving you my objective take on this - you are more than qualified to take on a project like this, and I think you should.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think this would be awesome. I've self-published a couple novels so I could give you some pointers on the technical stuff, and I'm a very neurotic proofreader (and a big fan of your writing!) so I'd be happy to beta-read!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think it's an awesome idea. I think you have so many resources / so much support from all the ladies on here - your sort of BLM group that you've connected with personally, and in person - that you could bring it together beautifully. Melissa has had her book about losing Ava published, she may have advice or contacts to advise about how tos and such. I can imagine maybe each lady takes a chapter / section that they feel particularly connected to? Maybe some input from BLgrandparents? Dads? Everyone could do a small section - as much or as little as they feel comfortable doing it - about their child, their loss, their particular journey through grief. Perhaps there's a more recently bereaved family who would want to express what they're dealing with in the more immediate aftermath. And you guys could control how you're represented, as BLM families, vs being someone's concept, when they can't possibly know what it is to hurt like that.

    Or, nothing at all like that. You probably have your own vision.

    But what Kristin said. You're a gifted writer. You're bereaved mother. Your ability to express how you're feeling and how you're dealing with those feelings is, like this idea, a gift. And if not now, when, really? Perhaps the idea came to you now bc now is the time, if you will. There's no kind of second hand embarrassment anyone will be feeling for you. This is a great idea.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I did not read all the books out there, but I did read quite a few, and found most very lacking and outdated. There is definitely a need for this and I'd be interested in helping.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think it sounds like a great idea. I may not be blogging anymore, but I'd be happy to help you out on this.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree that this is needed, Brooke, and I spent a while thinking that I might personally take on an updating of "Empty Cradle, Broken Heart." An editor I know who works in the maternal health publishing world offered to help me. But I also knew that I would have to wade back into that grief for months or even years to tackle a book. I wanted to be able to enjoy my life and my living kids.

    So, if you would like help, let me know. A group effort might make this much more doable.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think it's a great idea. Your posts have made me cry, but also laugh. Everything is honest, embarrassing, raw, and real. You should go for it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think you should. You are an incredibly gifted writer and your blog helped me immensely in the early days of grief, especially since our timelines of loss and rainbow children are so similar. I know you don't know me (I don't blog for a number of personal reasons that I am happy to go into via email). I would be happy to proof read if you need volunteers.
    kaela.wilson@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  10. Yes! I just saw this blog entry and had to comment asap. All I wanted in the beginning (and even now) was a step by step guide of how to get through it. This is exactly what I wanted to do as well but don't have the time, patience, words, etc.(I think we actually spoke about it on my blog at the start of my journey) and I think you absolutely need to do it! I would be happy to help in any way I can.

    I was one of those people that found you and emailed you. You & your blog have helped me in ways I could never really properly thank you for. You are the perfect person for this and I am a BIG fan of this idea. :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Oh I have so much to say about this. First of all, I am one of those people who went to your black hole of grief archives, read them all, and emailed you. Honestly, I wasn't able to read much of your current blog until Josephine was safely born because I was so scared I would never parent a living daughter, and it was just hard to read about your girls. I know Justin read it all too. I did a lot of math- how far is Brooke away from Eliza's death? That must be how I will feel in a month or so (not totally rational I know but I was looking for hope that eventually I would fee normal again). I so needed this book just a year ago. I get a lot of emails from newly bereaved mothers reading my blog too. Just today I got an email asking for my advice on what to do with her daughter's nursery. Can that be a chapter? how to deal with THE STUFF? I can see moms and dads each writing a few paragraphs on each topic and compiling them in each chapter, because obviously many of us us different ways of dealing with everything.


    I was just told I should write a book yesterday. I would love to, but I have no idea where I would begin. But I am a REALLY good proofreader (when I am not on my phone anyway) and would love to help with this specific project.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think you are just the right person to take this on. In your spare time, right? :)
    I'd love to help.
    I think your blog is still relevant to recent baby loss parents because it shows progress and a lighter side to life that the newly bereaved need to believe will come to them too, in time. You also show a never ending connection and love for Eliza that exists alongside the lightness of everyday life, and I was so desperate in those early days to know how people managed to hold tight to their lost child as they moved forward with living.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Re-read what Kristin said. Then read it again. Then listen to her.

    Duh.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I think it's a great idea. Nothing exists that's candid and current. I'm an editor and writer, and fellow baby loss mom (I was one of those people who emailed you after my loss in 2014). I'd be grateful to be able to help out in any capacity.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I've been reading your blog for almost 6 years, you're an incredible writer and I'd love to read your book. Your voice is always authentic and real. I would go for it!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Yes, yes, yes...a book would be great. I'm another fellow BLM with a similar timeline [lost my first baby, a girl, in August 2010; went on to have 2 living children after that loss (another girl born in March 2013 and a son born in November 2014)]. Your blog was one I found while I was still in that first year of grief...it was such a lifeline. And now, 5.5 years out, I still read. I love how you remember Eliza while still enjoying the life you lead now with Zuzu and Coco. That is what I try to emulate with my kids...remembering their older, "baby" sister but still living a fun life with them. I would love to read a book you write about all this...and though I'm not a writer, I'd love to help out any way I can.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Yes, yes, yes! I found your blog (and probably e-mailed you) and it just helped me to see that someone could survive something as horrific as losing a baby. At the time, I just needed to know it was possible. Please write the book and if you want any input, we'll all be here for you.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Yes Brooke, you were a guiding light for me. Do it! Make a plan, get going, and I truly believe things will come together to make it happen

    ReplyDelete
  19. I'm definitely part of the support club on this! I know in the beginning I craved a story JUST LIKE MINE, which would obviously be difficult to find, but maybe with enough contributors you could cover almost all scenarios.

    I would also like to comment that your blog is unique in that it didn't start as a BLM blog, like so many of ours did. People witnessed as if in real time this terrible tragedy as it unfolded in your life. Your readers were as blindsided as you were. And that is a very powerful connection that I think you could leverage in introducing the concept of the book. Keep us posted!! (I'm logged in on my phone and not sure how my identity will come up. It's E from A Sky for Blue and Lawyer Mommy 484.)

    ReplyDelete
  20. I'm a black hole reader too. Write it!

    One thing I'd love to see in writing is How To Survive When There Is No Rainbow. Maybe a chapter of the book? I tried to start a section on glow like this. I just hate that so much out there is "healing" based on having more kids....not everybody can.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is an excellent point. My blogger-friend Lori writes about this a lot at http://theroadlesstravelledlb.blogspot.com/

      For so many people, life without a rainbow seems like the most devastating outcome possible, but the truth is that many people forge beautiful and meaningful and--eventually--happy lives even after experiencing the loss of a child and not having more children. Thanks for the feedback. xo

      Delete